Referees standards

Discuss all matters related to Dagenham and Redbridge
BB-Dagger
Posts: 628
Joined: Mon Feb 03, 2014 8:32 am

After tonight's diabolical display by the referee I wonder just how much training these tossers have,
The penalty was such a dive it amazes me that 'this clown has been let loose on such an important match.
Time wasting from as early as 10th minute escaped the attention of the officials, blatant diving went unpunished, it's been never ending all season! Is it just ours or do most conference games have these standards.
Lcbdagger
Posts: 1921
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 9:17 pm

Just heard the BT Sport commentary and they were equally scathing about the penalty... thankfully we got back in to it following some awful defending
Richie
Posts: 705
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2013 9:52 am

Tbf, I, and everyone around me in the TBS thought it was a pen. He'd have had a similar view.
mickeyblue
Posts: 707
Joined: Tue Mar 11, 2014 6:29 pm

Richie wrote:Tbf, I, and everyone around me in the TBS thought it was a pen. He'd have had a similar view.
yep he was 200ft from play
but we finished 9th!
Mark
Posts: 1598
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 5:04 pm

Penalty or not the referee had a mare throughout. We seemed to be on the wrong end of most of it and it continually stopped our momentum.

The failure of refs every week to do something about time wasting is doing my head in. We've come to watch football not people walking about.
RM1Dagger
Posts: 334
Joined: Mon Mar 13, 2017 12:40 am

I'm not sure how anyone in the TBS could call it either way..from my view (TBS) you just see a player go down..it's only seeing the replay you can then see it wasn't. The ref was obviously considerably closer but still gave a shit decision.
Now the SE27 Dagger
SUSSEX DAGGER
Posts: 2619
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2013 2:47 am

No point in moaning about the penalty as the boss says you can only control the controllable.

Sadly we have no control over the way Referees are being made mugs of each and every week. Before we stone to death tonights latest pathetic excuse of a referee then as the Good Lord said "let he who is without sin cast the first stone"

The end is nigh for blatant cheats like tonight's culprit, as after the next World Cup Video replays will be a cert and only then will justice roll down like a mighty stream

One quick look at a replay will prove he was cheating tonight and seen him booked.

When this is brought in and it almost certainly will, the other alteration to the rule I would like to see in such circumstances is to do away with the obligatory caution as that has proved to be a total failure in preventing incidents like tonight's.

The Punishment for proven cheating is to re-start the game with a penalty kick the other end. When cheats are dealt with in such a manner then we may see this filth eradicated from the game.

I forgive the referee for that mistake because most of us made our minds up after seeing a replay a luxury that is not offered to him.

Now as for a number of other decisions well that's a different matter.
Adrian
Posts: 1261
Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2014 4:09 pm

Mark wrote:Penalty or not the referee had a mare throughout. We seemed to be on the wrong end of most of it and it continually stopped our momentum.

The failure of refs every week to do something about time wasting is doing my head in. We've come to watch football not people walking about.
This. Time wasting is one of the easiest thing a to deal with, especially when it's as blatant as it has been at several games this season.
The one last night where their player just dribbled the ball away from a foul and then kicked 20 yards was a joke and as easy a booking as you could see.
He didn't even get spoken to.
Adrian
Posts: 1261
Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2014 4:09 pm

SUSSEX DAGGER wrote:No point in moaning about the penalty as the boss says you can only control the controllable.

Sadly we have no control over the way Referees are being made mugs of each and every week. Before we stone to death tonights latest pathetic excuse of a referee then as the Good Lord said "let he who is without sin cast the first stone"

The end is nigh for blatant cheats like tonight's culprit, as after the next World Cup Video replays will be a cert and only then will justice roll down like a mighty stream

One quick look at a replay will prove he was cheating tonight and seen him booked.

When this is brought in and it almost certainly will, the other alteration to the rule I would like to see in such circumstances is to do away with the obligatory caution as that has proved to be a total failure in preventing incidents like tonight's.

The Punishment for proven cheating is to re-start the game with a penalty kick the other end. When cheats are dealt with in such a manner then we may see this filth eradicated from the game.

I forgive the referee for that mistake because most of us made our minds up after seeing a replay a luxury that is not offered to him.

Now as for a number of other decisions well that's a different matter.

Not sure why youve mentioned replays. Most of us knew it wasn't a penalty at the game and unless I missed something we didn't have replays.

Yesterday's ref was the same one that sent Doe off at Torquay.

He was out of his depth from the first minute yesterday.
Diggerthedog
Posts: 3960
Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 6:08 pm

And he is in charge for the second leg, hopefully he will give us a dodgy penalty to even it up.

When you seen that performance you've got to wonder if Dale Vince visited the dressing room before the game with a brown envelope.
SUSSEX DAGGER
Posts: 2619
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2013 2:47 am

Adrian wrote:
SUSSEX DAGGER wrote:No point in moaning about the penalty as the boss says you can only control the controllable.

Sadly we have no control over the way Referees are being made mugs of each and every week. Before we stone to death tonights latest pathetic excuse of a referee then as the Good Lord said "let he who is without sin cast the first stone"

The end is nigh for blatant cheats like tonight's culprit, as after the next World Cup Video replays will be a cert and only then will justice roll down like a mighty stream

One quick look at a replay will prove he was cheating tonight and seen him booked.

When this is brought in and it almost certainly will, the other alteration to the rule I would like to see in such circumstances is to do away with the obligatory caution as that has proved to be a total failure in preventing incidents like tonight's.

The Punishment for proven cheating is to re-start the game with a penalty kick the other end. When cheats are dealt with in such a manner then we may see this filth eradicated from the game.

I forgive the referee for that mistake because most of us made our minds up after seeing a replay a luxury that is not offered to him.

Now as for a number of other decisions well that's a different matter.

Not sure why youve mentioned replays. Most of us knew it wasn't a penalty at the game and unless I missed something we didn't have replays.

Yesterday's ref was the same one that sent Doe off at Torquay.

He was out of his depth from the first minute yesterday.
Of course you did just like the Offside decision you got spot on the other week when Benson was clearly onside after the ball was last played by an opponent.

Like last nights Referee I am not without human frailties and a quick look at a replay (irrelevant in one case because Benson missed ) would have proved one decision was spot on and the other totally wrong.

You really are wasted to the game , you are obviously get things spot on 100% of the time. At least last nights Ref offers himself up to Public ridicule give him credit for that. The question has to be asked if the job is that easy why are we not all doing it ?
Dagdale
Posts: 1213
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 9:33 pm

Thoroughly enjoyed experiencing Non League football for the first time this season, the people you meet on the road, the way other clubs especially the minnows go about their business scraping the barrel to stay afloat and still trying to entertain and welcome fans from all over, points are so precious to keeping a club alive or dive and the refereeing this season on more than a handful of occasions concerning us alone has been awful. I get the issue its 'split second decisions' and human error always may occur, but don't think I've ever seen a season where the standard has been so bad, and even more crazy that I will say the NL board do seem to want to make our divisions more attractive and entertaining, so really hope on the coming season they take note, because other club's fan's are saying the same.
Adrian
Posts: 1261
Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2014 4:09 pm

SUSSEX DAGGER wrote:
Adrian wrote: Not sure why youve mentioned replays. Most of us knew it wasn't a penalty at the game and unless I missed something we didn't have replays.

Yesterday's ref was the same one that sent Doe off at Torquay.

He was out of his depth from the first minute yesterday.
Of course you did just like the Offside decision you got spot on the other week when Benson was clearly onside after the ball was last played by an opponent.

Like last nights Referee I am not without human frailties and a quick look at a replay (irrelevant in one case because Benson missed ) would have proved one decision was spot on and the other totally wrong.

You really are wasted to the game , you are obviously get things spot on 100% of the time. At least last nights Ref offers himself up to Public ridicule give him credit for that. The question has to be asked if the job is that easy why are we not all doing it ?
I'd guess the reason you're not doing it is because you don't understand the offside law.
The ball hitting a defender after being played by an attacker does not make another attacking player onside.
Benson was in an offside position when the ball was played by his team mate and gained an advantage from being in that position. The ball making contact with an opponent before reaching him is irrelevant.

If the opponent had controlled the ball and then deliberately played it to where Benson was he would t have been offside.
Daggernewbie
Posts: 852
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2016 10:37 pm

Diggerthedog wrote:And he is in charge for the second leg, hopefully he will give us a dodgy penalty to even it up.

When you seen that performance you've got to wonder if Dale Vince visited the dressing room before the game with a brown envelope.
Don`t you mean a green envelope Digger
:lol:
User avatar
Mike the Dagger
Posts: 2307
Joined: Mon Oct 28, 2013 9:09 am
Contact:

Daggernewbie wrote:
Diggerthedog wrote:And he is in charge for the second leg, hopefully he will give us a dodgy penalty to even it up.

When you seen that performance you've got to wonder if Dale Vince visited the dressing room before the game with a brown envelope.
Don`t you mean a green envelope Digger
:lol:
Many colours available... https://www.eco-craft.co.uk/envelopes.html
Post Reply